Splurge vs. Steal: Pastoral or Waterfront in the Hamptons

Is there any second home locale as iconic as the Hamptons? Super-rich New Yorkers have long escaped the city to spend summers in the Hamptons, reveling in the bucolic atmosphere and beachside fun. 

Which of these Bridgehampton retreats would you choose: the waterfront contemporary for a Splurge or the elegantly-designed, farmhouse-chic vibe for a Steal?

Splurge: Waterfront Contemporary for $17 Million

This Splurge has a lot going for it: prime waterfront location, a striking, boxy architectural design and a private pier. And of course, we’re always here for a floating stairs moment. With so many window-centric walls, there’s naturally an abundance of light. The interior is modern, glossy. And there’s no need to redecorate or search for a staging piece you caught feelings for– the house is being sold furnished.

From the listing:

“Sited on .40 acre on Mecox Bay at the end of Flying Point Road, this impeccable modern home, designed by the renowned architectural firm of Stelle Lomont Rouhani with Associated Interiors by Eleanor Donnelly, is a stunning tribute to masterful modern design. The property features a waterfront 16 x 32′ heated Gunite pool and dock, an outdoor shower, garage/cabana covered outdoor seating and dining area on the pool level, and thoughtful, well-articulated landscaping, both front and back.”

Steal: Elegant Pastoral for $8.5 Million

At the same size (3,300-square-foot) and the same number of bedrooms (four), our Splurge offers a more farmhouse-chic aesthetic for a multimillion price cut. Swapping waterside location for a peaceful, secluded lot, this home is surrounded by the pastoral beauty the Hamptons are famous for, including a horse farm and agricultural reserves. 

The warm interior included natural wood plank walls and ceilings, strong geometric lines and heated stone floors.

From the listing: 

“New to the market, enjoy this rare collector’s opportunity to own the renovated and restored former home of pioneering architect, Norman Jaffe, situated on a stunning, exceptionally private 1.1-acre, flag lot on Lumber Lane in Bridgehampton. The impeccably finished 4 bedroom, 4 bath compound offers several flexible living spaces organized around a courtyard oasis defined by elegant legacy trees, a sophisticated, heated pool with inset spa, and expansive stone patios for a seamlessly blended indoor / outdoor living experience that speaks to the integrity of Jaffe’s singular design.”